Reviews

Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
BS
Brandon S.

12/21/2016

Overall
Atmosphere
Food
Service

Great experience at this restaurant, parking is good and the service was better than i expected it to be

Doris D.

09/07/2015

Overall

Over 30 years I have gone to Sammy's Fish Box, and seen its improvement, it was more about taking friends there as a novelty then for terrific food. Today I can say everything was better than ever, and can now place you guys in the five star food and service category. The prime rib was slamming and so was my friends NY strip. YOU guys Rock!!!

AA
Angi A.

08/31/2014

Overall

I won't be back to Sammy's Fish Box. If you go, expect huge portions of over-priced, under-seasoned frozen food. It was noisy, crowded and kind of grimy. They packed us in like hogs to a trough. It was not the relaxing dining experience I was looking for. If not for our cheerful and attentive waitress I would have given Sammy's one star.



While waiting in line to be seated at a cramped table we were subjected to a sleazy manager named Steve verbally abusing and curse out a waitress in front of us. It was appalling and unprofessional. Her crime was seating a lucky party of two at a four person table.



Our two seater was so small they could barely fit the bread plates, relish tray, salad bowls, wine glasses, and finally entrée platters on the tiny table. The busboy didn't bring us water until we asked the waitress halfway through the meal, and even then they had to remove a bread plate here, and salad bowl there to negotiate room for the water glasses.



If you enjoy paying a lot of money for bland, previously frozen seafood served in a rowdy atmosphere, then Sammy's is the place for you.

Overall

They food was GREAT but the waitress, young girl, with the blond streaks in her hair made our experience POOR tonight. We had to ask for water, napkins, and even the plastic bibs. Food was worth the $120 but won't come back. I don't like to beg.

MiltonR594

05/31/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Ambiance Is Great. Food & Drinks even

Ambiance Is Great. Food & Drinks even better.. My wife and I had cocktails and dinner at Sammy's on City Island a few days ago and as always we were very happy with the experience. The Restaurant has been around since the 60's and looks like it opened yesterday. This is a fun place. I am the 3rd generation of my family going to Sammy's and were working on the 4th..

samjay91

05/19/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Seafood, Mojitos and more

I am not a great letter writer but I just had to say that I recently dined at Sammy's on City Island and had a fantastic evening. The staff and food were five star as well as the decor was so cool, I felt like I was eating at one of those great feeling Disney theme restaurants. I must add that my wife and I shared a 5lb lobster that was the best I ever had.

bobspitzs

05/19/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Best BBQ since I moved from Texas.

I am a huge BBQ fan since my college days in Austin Texas. Last week my friend invited me to dinner up on City Island at Sammy's Fishbox. I would have rather gone to a BBQ place but since I was a guest it wasn't my choice.. To my surprise Sammy's had the best Baby Back Ribs I have ever eaten, They were succulent and tender off the bone. I had a Rib and whole lobster combination that was so good. The restauarant had a wonderful vibe as well, can't wait to go back..

paulio169

05/19/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Melt in your mouth menu

We were a party of 20 and purposely ordered 20 different appetizers and 20 different entrees as is the custom when our club eats out.. I just could not believe it that this was the first time after meeting at countless restaurants over the last 5 years that every single dish was a winner. What a great restaurant, Sammy's is on the top of our list. We are all planning to have another meeting there next month..This will be the first time we have return to a restaurant for our club meeting..

MedMan

05/07/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Best seafood restaurant in NYC

I first came here in the 1980's but haven't been back because I now live out of state. Went back this weekend with some guests and it's every bit as good as ever. My favorite is the fried combination platter, with one serving you can eat yourself to overflowing and still take home enough for a full meal for another day. The reason you come here is for large portions of great tasting fresh seafood, what else is there to say? Sure the entrees run $35 - $40 but you get what you pay for. I've never met anyone who's been here, who didn't want to go back again and again. And the valet parking is free.

izabelaf

04/15/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
What a mistake.....

One the worst restaurant experiences I ever had. The food was not good at all. I ordered the fillet of sole and boy was that a mistake.the batter they use is pretty bad. My daughter threw up in a disgusting bathroom half way through the meal. she had the crab legs with the shell steak. The waiter was nice but never around. I felt like I was being robbed when I had to pay the ridiculously over priced bill.
Giving this place 5 stars is a complete joke !!

Mikecortez

03/30/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Eh, is right, Don't believe the hype

I'm not sure what all the five star reviews are about. Seems fake to me, that many people writing raving reviews.

foojo

01/29/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
The Crab Legs are absolutely best!

Sammy's is the best seafood restaurant in New York. The whole Lobster Newburg was simple but awesome tasting. The huge portion of fresh grilled fish of the day is a bargain, but the crab legs are the absolute best! Decor and service is really funky and cozy,

Nikihams

01/22/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
If Seafood is your thing, Than Sammy's is your Place

I love seafood and when we go out my husband and I always go seafood. I don't know of any other restaurant that that matches the quality and portion size that Sammy's affords us. I love Fresh fish and they have a daily list of at least 12 types of fresh fish. they recently had artic char, a fish I never had before, it was fantastic. I had it cajun style. My husband and daughter shared one of Sammy's famous Crab feasts, . It was enough for us to have for dinner the following evening.
I highly recommend this restaurant if you love fresh seafood, giant portions and a fun staff, who always treats us right.

tomcoss

01/19/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Warm And Inviting

I went here for new years eve and was pleasantly surprised. Food was great. and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The large crackling fireplace was warm and inviting . I can't wait to return. It was a real surprise finding such a wonderful restaurant on City Island in the Bronx..I am so glad I watched the movie City Island with Andy Garcia otherwise I would never have thought to visit City Island.

Redbigman

01/18/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
fantastic Raw Bar

Always outstanding. The raw bar is a good as they get, supported by a great staff and very fresh seafood. I consistently rate the oysters, little necks as well as the Shrimp cocktail ""the best I've ever had"". I f you get there late, be prepared to wait. It's worth it.

jesswill

01/18/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
The only Seafood Restauarant i continually go back to

When I moved to NYC a few years ago from Maine, Being a seafood lover, I tried at least 50 seafood restuarants in the five boro's and none of them warranted a return visit except Sammy's on City Island. My wife Julie and I go to Sammy's at least once a week religiously..The food is stupendous and the staff treat us like royality..especially Leslie and Steve ,,My favorite dish is the !/2 of 3lb lobster stuffed with crab meat..Julie always tries a new dish and is always delighted with her choice..
I highly recommend a trip to Sammy's..

nacyKaz

01/18/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Lobster, Lobster, Lobster

..
I love lobster especially the way they prepare and serve it at Sammy's Fishbox. I really love their Lobster combination plates… I most enjoy the Whole lobster and baby back rib combo plate. I request a female lobster, because the tail has more meat than a male lobster. Then I ask that it be stuffed with crabmaet..wWow me getting hungry just thinking about it as I right this.
Sammy's a great spot. I ALWAYS RUN ITO FAMILY AND FRIENDS WHEN I AM THERE…

Dan38

01/07/2012

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Bust

What a bust!

Do people actually go to this place?

I have had plenty of very good dining experiences on City Island, and decided to try Sammy's during the off season.

Do people go here because parking is convenient and it's easy to get a seat? I can't see why else you would.

The service, while not terrible, was not very helpful. Our waiter could not answer many of the questions we had (are the chicken fingers real chicken or grounded, do you have Guinness). There was a language barrier.

We were seated right away, which was nice...until we sat.

The seats dip down like you're in a bucket seat of a nascar. I could not have been further away from the person across from me, which means we had to talk loudly.

The seats are also very flimsy. The person seated in the booth behind me was drunk and moving around--making it feel similar to an earthquake.

Drinks were next: Waiter said there was no sparking wine, so we went with Pinot Grigio (which we later found out was $9 dollars a glass and tasted awful).

I don't mind spending $9 dollars a glass, but not for some awful place in the Bronx.

I ordered a guinness, and was served a guinness extra stout. No biggie, I don't mind extra stout, but for someone who does, a heads-up would be nice.

Soup was next. I went to City Island primarily for my hankering for lobster bisque. What I got was puzzling: A big bowl of what tasted and looked like velveeta chese, without much of a hint of lobster to be found.

From that point on, the meal was pretty much ruined.

The clams were O.K.

The bill did not help matters. We came in just after 3 and they would not make anything off of the lunch menu, which makes a seafood dinner menu tough for kids and land-lovers. No sandwiches at all would be made, but they conveniently said they would do chicken fingers and fries.

The chicken fingers and fries came out 20 dollars! Without telling us the price before hand or having it on the menu.

Worst meal I've ever had. No doubt about it. STAY AWAY!

labryant

07/28/2011

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Had A Wonderful Meal and Time

My uncle and I were making plans for my grandparent's and grandfather's birthday weekend celebration (May 16th and 18th). He mentioned to me about Sammy's last year because it had great seafood, but the prices were a bit steep. He and a group of friends went before and had food leftover because the portions were so big. It sounded so good, when he mentioned it again I thought it was a good idea. My grandparents very seldom go out to new places and this would be a good excuse.

My mother and I surprised them that weekend and I told them where we were going. They too were excited to eat there. When we got there the place was packed from the door to the host stand. Let me say when I put our name on the list I didn't have to wait extremely long either. I was seated in less than 30 minutes (if that) and was greeted shortly there after by the floor manger (a nice woman who checked on us throughout the night).

When I saw the menu I damn near choked. I couldn't get over so many options and I decided to go for Maryland crabackes (large and plentiful the whole table ate off of them), a small salad before the meal, pasta on the side, shrimp scampi and crab legs. LORD THAT WAS THE BEST SEAFOOD MEALL I HAD IN A LONG TIME!!!! Not only was the food hot and fresh, the crab legs came with a some type of coating on them, the shrimp scampi was done very well, and I had plenty to take back home with to Maryland. The rest of family dined on large meals as well. My grandfather ordered the Snapper stuffed with crabmeat and it looked scrumptious.

What made the night so special was the complimentary two glasses of champagne for my grandparents anniversary and a slice of red velvet cake. My server, her name is Dorian (hope she is still there and someone sees this), was excellent. She stayed on top of everything and took our orders promptly and correctly.

I recommend this place to anyone who wants good seafood

ElizabethfromGreenwich

03/19/2011

Provided by Citysearch
Overall
Love It!

I love it!

It's the best!
I'm coming back!

Details

Phone: (718) 885-0920

Address: 41 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464

Website: http://www.sammysfishbox.com

More Info

General Info
Sammy's Shrimp Box was established in 2005. Formally Known as Tito Puente's Restaurant, Sammy's continues the great tradition of serving only the very best and freshest food to our dedicated customers. Only at the Shrimp Box we kept several of our famous Latino dishes and fabulous frozen tropical drinks. Since the beginning we believe some things are as true today as they were years ago; quality attracts customers, value earns respect and compromise in either is innappropriate. Our formula here at the Shrimp Box is very simple and traditional, just like at Sammy's Fish Box; serve the very best quality food, prepared Fresh daily in an uncomprimising manner and served in generous portions at affordable prices. We at Sammy's Shrimp Box wish to thank you, our customers, for your loyalty in the past and we promise to earn more of that loyalty in the future. Sincerely, SammySammy's Shrimp Box was established in 2005. Formally Known as Tito Puente's Restaurant, Sammy's continues the great tradition of serving only the very best and freshest food to our dedicated customers. Only at the Shrimp Box we kept several of our famous Latino dishes and fabulous frozen tropical drinks. Since the beginning we believe some things are as true today as they were years ago; quality attracts customers, value earns respect and compromise in either is innappropriate. Our formula here at the Shrimp Box is very simple and traditional, just like at Sammy's Fish Box; serve the very best quality food, prepared Fresh daily in an uncomprimising manner and served in generous portions at affordable prices. We at Sammy's Shrimp Box wish to thank you, our customers, for your loyalty in the past and we promise to earn more of that loyalty in the future. Sincerely, Sammy
Extra Phones

Phone: (718) 509-6367

Phone: (718) 885-3200

Fax: (718) 885-0187

Payment method
all major credit cards
Price Range
$$$
Neighborhood
City Island
Categories
Other Information

Parking: Lot, Free

Wi-Fi: No

Bike Parking: Yes

Attire: Casual

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Cuisines: Caterers, Family Style, American, Seafood

Alcohol: Beer, Wine

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: Yes

People Also Viewed